GMO’s unacceptable elsewhere, good enough for Americans: Japan Suspends Some Imports of U.S. Wheat

US corn, sugar, canola oil and soy produced and sold in the US is
genetically modified. That includes most food for human as
well as animal consumption.  Monsanto has had patents on GMO wheat
since the 1990s.  

However, wheat is the US’ largest export crop.
Rather than being fed to livestock or unwary Americans, half is
shipped overseas. Because importing countries (including Europe, China
and Japan) don’t want GMO wheat (it still isn’t approved for consumption in a
single country), it is illegal in the US to grow it, outside “highly
controlled” test plots.  
From the NY Times came this clumsy statement, which implies that processed foods made from GMOs are not consumed by people.  Of course they are:  an estimated 70% of processed food in the US contains GMOs.  Widespread consumer resistance to GMOs in the US has failed to impact Monsanto’s influence on lawmakers.  But consumer resistance outside the US means that US farmers can’t sell Monsanto’s GMOs overseas, and wheat exports are critical to the US economy.  This has spared US consumers from GMO wheat, so far.

most American soybeans and corn are genetically modified, those crops
are largely consumed by animals or made into processed foods. Wheat is
consumed directly by people and there has been more consumer
resistance. No genetically engineered wheat has been approved in any
country. Indeed, one reason Monsanto dropped its development of
genetically modified wheat in 2004 was concern from American farmers
that it would endanger wheat exports. 

has now resumed research into genetically modified wheat but says it
will be at least a decade before any such crop reaches the market…

In 2006, after
traces of an unapproved genetically engineered rice were found in the
American harvest, rice prices dropped, at least temporarily, and
exports slowed.Bayer
CropScience, the company that developed and field-tested the rice,
agreed to pay $750 million to settle claims with about 11,000 American

some (how much? enough to cause the price to plummet) Monsanto-bred,
US-grown wheat found its way into farmers’ fields.  And experts suggest
it has probably been there for awhile.

consumer product regulation is arguably the weakest among developed
countries at this point.  Fortunately for the Japanese and most
Europeans, their regulators are still on the job.  And in record time, Japan and the European Union told us we could put this American wheat where the sun don’t shine.

legislators and regulators have passed legislation banning the labeling
of GMO products, because they know that Americans, if warned, will shun
them too. From the WP:

The United States already relies heavily on genetically modified crops.
Genetically engineered corn, cotton and soybeans have gone from 5 to 17
percent of the U.S. market in 1997 to between two-thirds and more than
90 percent in 2012. By some estimates, more than 70 percent of
processed foods sold in the United States contain ingredients and oils
from genetically engineered crops.

Monsanto and other companies in the industry have been pressing members
of Congress to vote against measures that would require disclosure for
food made with genetically modified or engineered crops. Friends of the
Earth, an environmental group, says that 64 countries have similar
rules and that, this year, 37 bills have been introduced in 21 states
proposing that genetically engineered foods be labeled in stores.

is also urging lawmakers to vote for a rider in the Senate continuing
resolution that would strip federal courts of the power to provide
injunctive relief to environmental and food activists seeking to stop
the spread of such crops.

modified crops have a history of provoking bans by trading partners. In
2006, the Agriculture Department announced that trace amounts of a
regulated variety of genetically engineered rice had been commingled
with supplies of conventional rice. That led several U.S. trading
partners to refuse U.S. rice exports, causing losses for U.S. farmers
and exporters.

And from Reuters:

… The discovery instantly roiled export markets, with Japan canceling a major shipment of wheat, a quick reminder of what is at stake – an $8 billion U.S. wheat export business. Many
fear the wheat most likely has been mixed in with conventional wheat
for some time, but there are no valid commercial tests to verify
whether wheat contains the biotech Roundup Ready gene. 

lot of people are on high alert now,” said Mike Flowers, a cereal
specialist at Oregon State University. “We can’t really say if it is or
isn’t in other fields. We don’t know…”

From RT:

major Asian importers like Korea, China and the Philippines said they
were closely monitoring the situation, while the European Union is set
to test any incoming shipments, saying it will block any containing GM

Following the announcement, wheat for July delivery fell 8.25 cents to $6.945 a bushel on the Chicago Board of Trade.   

wheat, created by Monsanto Co., appeared on an 80-acre farm in Oregon
in April. On Wednesday, the US Department of Agriculture (USDA) said it
had conducted a genetic test on the wheat and found that it was an
experimental type created by the US agribusiness giant which had never
been approved for sale. 

USDA has never approved any GMO strain of wheat to be grown in the US,
but Monsanto field tested a genetically engineered variety from 1998
through 2005. It was never put into use however, due to global
opposition to genetically engineered cereal grains. Wheat remains an
exception however, as more than 60 genetically modified crops have been
approved for US food and feed supplies.

top three GMO crops grown in the US are soy, corn and cotton, according
to the USDA. Some Eighty-eight perc ent of corn and 93 pe rcent of
soybeans grown in the US are genetically modified.  

the United States produces only 10 percent of world wheat it is
consistently the world’s biggest wheat exporter. With world trade in
wheat greater than for all other crops combined, Wednesday’s findings
could dent US export prospects at a time when the USDA is expecting
record global production, boosted by a 48 percent hike in Russian
output and a 40 percent gain from Ukraine.  

the USDA says US exports will likely fall 9.8 percent to 25.2 million
tons in the year that starts on June 1, Bloomberg reports.    

This is not something we need to see when exports are suffering anyway,
Darrell Holaday, the president of Advanced Market Concepts in Wamego,
Kansas, told the New York based agency in a telephone interview.

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Scroll to Top